Richard Watson answers Justice Objection to Original Sin
Many Christians object to the idea that we are condemned in Adam. But the same objectors often hold we receive a sin nature from Adam and that due to the fall we will physically die. Richard Watson highlights the logical inconsistency with this objection: The justice of this is objected to, a point which will be immediately considered; but it is now sufficient to say, that in the making the descendants of Adam liable to eternal death, because of his offence, be unjust, the infliction of temporal death is so also; the duration of the punishment making no difference in the simple question of justice. If punishment, 'whether of loss or of pain, be unjust, its measure and duration may be a greater or a less injustice; but it is unjust in every degree. If, then, we only confine the hurt we have received from Adam to bodily death; if this legal result of his transgression only be imputed to us, and we are so constituted sinners as to b...